?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

I have no interest in reading 50 Shades of Grey to start with. The whole learning to be a sub melodrama is as bad as the average BDSM poem. The Hulk puked in Aunt May's washing machine on an Ultimate Spiderman rerun last night. Same thing. That said:

I would be horrifically PO'd to find out that I paid money for a book that tons of people had read for free elsewhere, and is probably still circulating for free.

The transition from fic to profic is yay-worthy enough. Using regurgitated fanfic as "profic" without telling people? That's crap. I wouldn't consider it "pirating" to distribute saved copies of the fanfic a profic was revamped from, either. I would consider it piracy for someone to pass off a free fic as something that must be now paid for. Turnitin rates 50 Shades as 89% the same copy as the fanfic it came from. Can we derive rip off from that?

I don't buy books from fic-thors I don't know who yank their fanfic because I'm not forking cash for something I've already read for free.

That's my take.

Comments

( 5 comments — Leave comment )
devo79
Sep. 11th, 2012 02:33 pm (UTC)
I'm very baffled by this whole 50 shades of grey thing.

I tried reading Twilight and True Blood but only got halfway through the first chapter in both cases and had to stop reading because I was laughing so damn hard. It was like reading a 13 year old's first wet dream.

I have a feeling that 50 shades of bleh is the same way.
muffiewrites
Sep. 12th, 2012 02:07 am (UTC)
I have a feeling you're right. I've read a few lines of it and it was ewwwwwww.
keire_ke
Sep. 11th, 2012 08:20 pm (UTC)
What's your take on fics which were rewritten as original from scratch, using the basic premise and character baselines? You can still tell it's the same story and some of the phrasing will inevitably repeat.
muffiewrites
Sep. 12th, 2012 02:17 am (UTC)
That's a little more difficult than a find and replace with a few spruced up to be original scene fixes. Plots repeat and, really, they aren't that original. Case in point: Hamlet and Sons of Anarchy or Taming of the Shrew and 10 Things I Hate About You. The basic premise of the plot is the same, the characters are the same "type", but the stories are refreshingly interesting. A good ficcer can take a fanfic premise and rewrite from scratch (not opening old fic) and come up with something that's different and refreshing, not the same story at all, despite similar characters and plot. It's kind of like how two people will write two separate fanfics with essentially the same plot, but both of them will look and feel different. Polly Bywater of Sentinel fandom calls that hivemind. I don't think it would be the same story, even if a few phrases here and there repeat. The reason: the setting and characters would necessarily be different. It's like Captain America and Superman. They're both perfect Boy Scouts. They're both "alien" in some way (time-displacement and non-human physiology). They both keep big cities safe in shiny red and blue costumes with their super powers. But nothing about them feels the same, even when the plots aren't much different. (Bad guy shows up, bad guy destroys things, hero shows up, hero gets beat up, at last minute hero wins, everyone rejoices).

It's not really the phrasing so much as that it's a case of selling a fic as something that hasn't been published before when most of it has.

Though to be fair to Ms. 50 Shades, I have no idea if she disclosed this information or if it got leaked. I'm giving her the benefit of the doubt and assuming she told people it was a mildly retooled fanfic for sale.
dimity_blue
Sep. 14th, 2012 04:56 pm (UTC)
Apparently the actual 50 Shades version is also floating around for free. I haven't read it (or the Twilight fanfic it was originally posted as), but I've heard a number of people complain that it's total crap, and one person say she enjoyed it.

I'm surprised at how popular it is. Guess EL James got lucky.
( 5 comments — Leave comment )